A hard week for AI shares, while value investors looked at Disney, Dollar General and Nike
Market Daily Brief
By Arthur Ledger: Sunday editorials and daily company notes
By Arthur Ledger
The shape of the week
Last Sunday we wrote about the first weekly gain in five weeks. It did not last. The S&P 500 fell on every day of the week, from 7,562 to 6,910, a drop of 8.6% according to Yahoo Finance closing prices. Friday alone took off 3.7%, and the Nasdaq fell further. Chip shares led the way down.
The odd part is that the worst-hit company had just reported a superb quarter. Nvidia's 8-K of 17 November shows revenue of $115.8bn, about double a year earlier, and a gross margin near 75%. Its shares still fell 23% on the week to $125.53, a 52-week low. The board has not finished looking for a successor to the founder who stepped down on 12 November. Meanwhile Anthropic's record listing pulled tens of billions of dollars toward one new AI share, the US 10-year yield stayed above 5%, and money moved toward staples, healthcare and utilities. When a market pays any price for growth one month and almost any price to get out the next, the businesses that simply earn cash start to look interesting again.
What we checked and scored
Friday's Market Daily Brief scored Anthropic at 5 out of 20: remarkable growth, but about 16 times run-rate sales for a company with no steady operating profit yet. Two Value Investors Club ideas, RH and Standard Nuclear, scored 7 and 4, both too hard on debt or thin firm orders. Copart stays at 17 while we wait for its first-quarter 10-Q, and this week's club check was blocked at the sign-in page.
Berkshire watch
The third-quarter 13F, filed on 16 November, was the main event: a new $689m stake in Bending Spoons, the Lennar holding doubled, more Delta Air Lines, trims to Bank of America, VeriSign, Kroger, Capital One and Nucor, and no full exits. The same day Berkshire's own news release set out Warren Buffett's annual Thanksgiving gifts: 6,150 class A shares converted into 9,225,000 class B shares and given to four family foundations, in line with the long-stated plan. His short message argued that kindness "compounds". An 8-K on 19 November confirmed that the five-tranche yen bond priced the week before has now been issued. There is no new annual letter.
What value investors on X and YouTube discussed
This morning's sweep read 153 new posts from 18 value investors on X and the descriptions of 20 relevant videos across 8 YouTube channels (YouTube blocked transcripts this week, so that side is headline-level only). Nvidia was again the most-discussed name, with Aswath Damodaran publishing a fresh valuation and Michael Burry posting often about the selloff. Anthropic's listing, weak US housing and debt-funded AI spending were the other big threads. Four ideas were pitched or rescored, and we checked each against company filings:
Walt Disney, 13 (posts by The Science of Hitting on its full-year results). The parks and the film library are a real moat, and at about 17 times adjusted earnings, with free cash flow above 5% of market value and $9bn of buybacks planned, the price is reasonable. Linear TV decline, sports-rights costs and a new chief executive hold it back.
Nvidia, 13 after rescoring. At about 12 times annualised earnings the price now gives some margin of safety, but those are peak-cycle profits from a few huge customers, and the management score drops while the top job is unfilled. The total is unchanged.
Dollar General, 12 (an older Science of Hitting note shared again). Rural store density and an improving turnaround at about 17 times earnings and a 7% free cash flow yield, set against a lawsuit filed by the FTC and several states in October, which its 8-K discloses.
Nike, 12 after rescoring, following its investor day. Cheaper at a 52-week low, but the new targets put a full recovery in 2029 to 2031, and the dividend is larger than free cash flow after stock pay.
Grandstand, the former Gambling.com, scored 6 and is too hard: debt and possible share-settled payments outweigh a low multiple.
Nothing new scored above 15 this week.
The patient reading
A falling market does not make a business worth less. It only changes the price on offer. This week it came down sharply on the most popular shares. We would rather do the work now, so that if a fine business ever reaches a sensible price we know it when we see it.
Arthur Ledger
Research only, not investment advice.
Chronicle