The Calver Chronicle

Published 05:00 BST · 2 stories

How Arthur Ledger Scores a Business

World

How Arthur Ledger Scores a Business

How we score a company →

Market Daily Brief

By Arthur Ledger: Sunday editorials and daily company notes

A plain-English guide to the scorecard behind our Markets stories. Research only, not investment advice.

Every company we write about gets the same test. It's a simple scorecard out of 20, and this page explains how it works so you can judge our scores for yourself.

WHERE IT COMES FROM
The scorecard isn't ours. We borrowed it from people who did the hard thinking first.
- Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger. Their Berkshire Hathaway shareholder letters cover what makes a good business, a good manager and a sensible price.
- Mohnish Pabrai's The Dhandho Investor. His big idea is "heads I win, tails I don't lose much": look for bets where the downside is small and the upside is large.
- Benjamin Graham, Philip Fisher and Peter Lynch. Graham gave us margin of safety, Fisher gave us quality and management, and Lynch gave us "buy what you understand".

THE TEN QUESTIONS
We ask ten questions. Each one scores 0, 1 or 2, so the most a business can get is 20.
1. Can we understand it? A 2 means we can explain how it makes money in a sentence or two. A 1 means we follow the gist but parts of it are murky. A 0 means it's outside our circle of competence.
2. Is it simple and slow-changing? A 2 is a business that will look much the same in ten years, like a railway or a soft-drinks maker. A 1 changes but at a pace we can follow. A 0 is one where technology or fashion can upend it quickly.
3. Does it have a moat that should last about ten years? A moat is whatever keeps rivals out: a brand, low costs, a network, switching costs or a licence. A 2 is wide and durable. A 1 is real but narrowing or unproven. A 0 means no moat.
4. Is management able and honest? A 2 means a record of sensible capital allocation, plain reporting and fair treatment of shareholders. A 1 means mixed or limited evidence. A 0 means a reason not to trust them, such as misleading accounts or self-dealing.
5. Does it earn good owner earnings and returns on capital? Owner earnings are, roughly, the cash an owner could take out each year without harming the business. A 2 means strong cash generation and high returns on the money invested. A 1 means adequate. A 0 means weak returns or profits that don't turn into cash.
6. Is there a margin of safety? This compares the price with our rough estimate of what the business is worth. A 2 means the price is well below value. A 1 means it's about fair. A 0 means it's expensive.
7. Heads I win, tails I don't lose much? A 2 means the downside looks limited, perhaps through net cash, hard assets or a cheap price. A 1 means some real risk of loss. A 0 means you could lose a lot.
8. Could you hold it for a long time? A 2 is a business you'd be comfortable owning for a decade without watching the price. A 1 needs regular checking. A 0 is a trade, not an investment.
9. Is it free of too much debt and speculation? A 2 means modest debt and a conservative balance sheet. A 1 means debt that is manageable but worth watching. A 0 means heavy borrowing or a business that depends on speculation.
10. Is it a proven idea? Pabrai calls this cloning: copying good ideas from investors with strong records is no shame. A 2 means respected long-term investors own it or have made a careful case for it. A 1 means some support. A 0 means none.

Continued in the next story.

How Arthur Ledger Scores a Business (continued)

How we score a company →

THE GATE: SOME ZEROS CAN'T BE OUTSCORED
Three questions matter so much that a zero on any of them overrides the total: management (4), downside (7) and leverage (9). If a business scores 0 on any of these, it goes in the "too hard" pile, whatever its total. Dishonest managers, big potential losses or heavy debt can wipe out an investor, and no amount of quality elsewhere makes up for that.

WHAT THE SCORES MEAN
- 15 or below: a one-line note. Many good companies land here, often because the price is too high.
- Above 15: a full brief covering the business, valuation, strengths and risks.
- 16 or more is rare. Most businesses fall short on at least a couple of questions, usually price.

HOW WE CHECK OUR WORK
A score is only as good as the facts behind it.
- Primary sources first. We start with company filings, such as SEC filings on EDGAR, annual reports and official results, before reading anyone's commentary.
- One-off gains come out. A large one-time gain, such as the sale of an asset or an investment, can make a year's profits look better than the business really is. We strip these out before scoring. More than once, this has lowered a score.
- Thin data is flagged. If we've only been able to check the price and not the filings, we say so, and the score should be read as provisional.

A VALUE LINE-STYLE OVERLAY
Alongside the 20-point score we add three ratings in the style of Value Line, the long-running US research service:
- Timeliness (1 to 5): how the shares might do relative to the market over the next year or so. 1 is best.
- Safety (1 to 5): how steady the business and its shares are. 1 is safest.
- Appreciation estimate: a rough range for where the price could go over the next few years.
These are our own estimates in that style. They are not official Value Line ratings.

WHAT WE LEAVE OUT
- No Chinese companies. We find it too hard to judge the governance and legal risks.
- No crypto companies. Their value rests too heavily on speculation.
- For our Value Investors Club screen, no bonds or ETFs. We score operating businesses, not securities or funds.

WHERE THE IDEAS COME FROM
- Weekly sweeps of well-known value investors on X and YouTube.
- Write-ups on the Value Investors Club.
- Screens of whole indices: the S&P 500, FTSE 100, Nasdaq-100, BIST 100 and a list of names on the Tokyo Stock Exchange.

WHAT THE SCORE IS NOT
The score is not a signal to buy or sell. It measures how a business stacks up against a set of principles, and those principles can still be applied badly. A business can score well on quality and still be a poor buy at today's price. If the margin of safety isn't there, the sensible thing is often to wait. As Buffett has long argued, a wonderful company at a silly price is not a bargain.

Everything here is research only, not investment advice. Do your own homework, and talk to a qualified adviser before making decisions with your money.

Source: Arthur Ledger (original explainer).