Market Daily Brief: A falling market is not a bargain bin
Market Daily Brief
By Arthur Ledger: Sunday editorials and daily company notes
Oil hits $114 and tech stocks slide after Meta's AI spending warning. We scored Rolls-Royce, Kering, Vonovia, Volvo Cars and Smith & Nephew from their own reports, and nothing cleared 15.
When the market sells everything in a hurry, it sometimes sells good businesses too. Today's FT was mostly about falling prices. Falling prices are not the same as bargains.
A nervous market
Brent crude touched $114.72, its highest since May, on fears of escalation in the Middle East. The Nasdaq 100 fell 2.9% on Thursday after Meta said it needs to raise hundreds of billions for AI, and Meta's own shares fell 7%. Investors ran to safety. The US 10-year Treasury yield fell to just under 5% after its best day since 2023. Calpers, the $640bn pension fund, cut its direct holdings of the biggest US tech stocks by 26% in the first half.
Meta: 10/20, unchanged from yesterday. Even after the fall it trades at about 25 times earnings with a cash yield of about 1.5%. When a safe government bond pays nearly 5%, that is a thin reward for the uncertainty of AI spending.
Rolls-Royce, a fine business at a full price
The FT reports that Rolls-Royce is close to a £100mn to £200mn UK subsidy for a new narrow-body engine. The company has not yet announced it, and it is small next to a market value of about £97bn.
Rolls-Royce: 12/20. Net cash of £2.1bn, investment-grade credit and up to £9bn earmarked for buybacks over 2026 to 2028. But at about 33 times trailing underlying earnings and a cash yield of about 4% on this year's guidance, the price already counts on a lot going right. We would like it more after a deeper fall.
Luxury loses its shine
Kering's shares fell about 12% to a 52-week low after third-quarter sales fell 1% to €3.35bn on a like-for-like basis, with Gucci down 6%. The group dropped its promise to return to growth and kept only its margin target.
Kering: 8/20. Even after the fall it is about 48 times trailing recurring earnings. Return on capital is only about 6%, and there are €3.3bn of net debt and €6.1bn of lease liabilities. A famous brand losing customers is not a moat until it proves otherwise.
Two that fail our test
Vonovia, Europe's largest landlord, faces Berlin plans to take apartment portfolios into public ownership at about €100,000 a flat, well below book value. The FT puts the possible hit at €8.4bn, about 60% of its market value. Our own check came out close to that.
Vonovia: 9/20, too hard. At €16.72 it trades at about a third of net asset value and about 10 times guided earnings. But net debt is €39.8bn, about 14 times operating profit before depreciation, and politics now sets part of the value. Cheap assets carrying heavy debt can stay cheap.
Volvo Cars swung to a SEK5.7bn quarterly loss as revenue fell 23%. It burned about SEK9bn of cash and is cutting 2,500 more jobs. The shares fell about 26% to a record low.
Volvo Cars: 5/20, too hard. It trades at about a fifth of book value, but it has no earnings or free cash flow to value. Its net cash has shrunk from SEK26.9bn to SEK1bn in nine months. China's Geely owns about 79%, which would put it outside our rules anyway.
Smith & Nephew: 11/20, unchanged. The FT reports that merger talks with Johnson & Johnson's orthopaedics unit collapsed over who would be chief executive. The company has made no announcement, and our score never assumed a deal. It trades at about 14 times adjusted earnings with a 6% cash yield.
Mention only: OpenAI is reported to be raising money at about $1.25tn, below the $1.4tn it first pitched. Anthropic and Hg plan a European AI consultancy, a possible worry for Accenture. Gillian Tett warns that the US Treasury is leaning on short-term borrowing.
Also on our desk (since Thursday)
- MSCI 15/20 (Thursday evening X sweep): a wonderful index business with 56% operating margins and 95% client retention, but at about 32 to 34 times earnings there is no margin of safety. The chief executive reportedly bought about $30mn of shares, which we could not yet confirm in filings. Around $450 to $480 a share it would clear our bar.
- Vertiv 10/20 (same sweep): data-centre power and cooling. It has almost no net debt but trades at about 44 times trailing earnings even after halving, and its fortunes ride on AI spending.
Nothing cleared 15 today. A falling market tests patience, not just prices. We would rather wait for a good business at a sensible price than buy a weak one because it got cheaper.
Research only, not investment advice.
Chronicle