The Calver Chronicle

Published 05:00 GMT+0 · 90 stories

Markets

Sunday editorial: The Budget, read by a patient owner

How we score a company →

By Arthur Ledger

Budgets make loud headlines and quiet differences. Wednesday's, the first from Chancellor John Healey, is no exception. The question for an owner of businesses is not whether the measures are popular, but which of them change what a company will earn over the next ten years. Most do not.

What was announced

Banks pay for the energy help. The bank surcharge rises from 3% to 6% for 15 months, from 1 January 2027 to 31 March 2028, raising £1.5bn. That money funds a £100 Household Energy Payment from January 2027 for up to 20 million households in council tax bands A to D in England, costing £2.6bn, plus an extension of the VAT cut on electricity to July 2027.

Savers and landlords pay more. From April 2027, tax on savings and property income rises to 24%, 44% and 49% at the basic, higher and additional rates, two points on top of the rise already planned. The cash Isa limit stays at £20,000, a First Time Buyer Isa replaces the Lifetime Isa from April 2029, and a Your First Home equity loan scheme gets £4.7bn of backed lending.

Elsewhere, Machine Games Duty on higher-stakes machines rises from 20% to 25%; business rates for retail, hospitality and leisure are frozen in real terms for two years; online marketplaces must collect VAT on UK sellers from October 2027; and from April 2027 a new scheme cuts electricity bills by up to 25% for over 10,000 energy-intensive firms.

The forecasts

The OBR raised 2026 growth to 1.2% but cut 2027 to 1.0%, from 1.6%. It sees inflation averaging 3.3% across 2026 and 2027 and real disposable income per person falling. Headroom against the fiscal rule is £15bn in 2029-30. The tax burden reaches a record 37.9% of GDP in 2027-28 and 38.6% in 2031-32, against 32.9% before the pandemic, driven mainly by frozen personal tax thresholds.

Who gains and who loses

Banks lose a little, for a while. We put the cost at perhaps 3-4% of Lloyds' earnings and about £0.25bn a year for NatWest, by our rough estimates. Both score 11/20: good franchises at fair, not cheap, prices. A temporary tax does not change the value of a deposit base; a permanent one would. The Treasury says this one will not be extended. Owners should hold it to that, but not panic over it.

Banks and building societies also gain something: the cash Isa cut was dropped, so cheap, sticky savings stay put.

Retailers and pubs get relief on rates. Tesco, 14/20 on our card, gains modestly; the bigger question for any grocer remains its margin, not its rates bill. Housebuilders get a new demand prop in the equity loan scheme, but help for buyers tends to lift prices as much as volumes. Machine-heavy gambling operators lose; we have not scored any of them. Energy-hungry manufacturers win on power costs.

What not to read into it

A Budget is a forecast wrapped in a political choice. The OBR revises its numbers every six months; the gilt market, with the 10-year yield above 5%, will judge the plan faster. The record tax burden matters more than any one measure: it squeezes household spending power and makes UK savers lean harder on Isas and pensions. That is a slow headwind, not a reason to sell good businesses.

For savers, the lesson is plain. With tax on interest and rent outside wrappers rising to 24% at the basic rate, the shelter matters more than ever.

For investors, one broker reckons UK shares are already the cheapest in the G10 on free cash flow. Nothing on Wednesday made a wonderful business ordinary, or an ordinary one wonderful.

What value investors discussed this week

The Anthropic listing filing dominated talk on X and YouTube; it is not a value case and we did not score it. Of the ideas we did score, VICI Properties and Adyen scored 15, Airbnb 14, Crocs 13, and Britain's Zotefoams 12. Nothing cleared 15.

Research only, not investment advice.

More from the Weekend edition, Sun 1 Nov 2026 →