Cheap prices, few bargains: Barclays, Tesla and Nestlé
Barclays is cutting jobs, Tesla has cut its 2030 target and Nestlé has lost Russia: plenty of low prices, but nothing cleared 15 today. Nestlé scores best at 13, a fair price for wonderful brands, while Tesla is too hard to value.
A cheap price and a good business are two different things. Today's FT offered plenty of the first and not much of the second.
A bank cutting to grow
Barclays plans to cut about 5,000 jobs, roughly 5% of staff, using AI. Third-quarter profit before tax rose 12% to £2.3bn, a little short of forecasts, as fixed-income trading fell 19% and equities had their best quarter in a decade. Next week's Budget could bring a new UK bank tax.
Barclays: 8/20, unchanged after the results. The shares trade at about 1 times tangible book value and 7.5 times earnings, once a one-off gain from selling a card portfolio is stripped out. Cheap, yes. But a big investment bank is hard to see inside, and its return on equity fell to 11.7% this quarter, from 16.1% in the second.
Tesla shrinks the dream
Tesla cut its 2030 goal to 5mn vehicles a year from 20mn. We read the quarterly filing: deliveries fell 2%, net profit fell over 40% to $787mn, and the company still plans to spend more than $20bn this year. Its board and SpaceX's are studying a merger.
Tesla: 6/20, too hard. The company has plenty of cash, but trailing free cash flow of $3.3bn is about 0.2% of a $1.5tn market value. Strip out paper gains on its SpaceX stake and the shares trade near 590 times underlying earnings. The price depends on robotaxis and robots. We cannot value that.
Nestlé loses Russia, finds volume
Nestlé stopped consolidating its Russian business after the Kremlin took control. It wrote off about SFr1.6bn of net assets and took a SFr1.4bn non-cash currency charge, which we strip out. Russia was about 2% of sales. Third-quarter organic growth of 4% beat forecasts, and sales volumes grew 2.8%.
Nestlé: 13/20. Wonderful brands and a dividend raised or held for 66 years. At about 19 times underlying earnings and a 4% cash yield, with debt near 3 times operating profit before depreciation, it is a fair price, not a bargain.
The rest of the list
Fortescue: 11/20. It trades at about 9 times last year's earnings and a 10% cash yield, with little net debt. But China's state buyer is holding back purchases, prices fell 10% and costs rose 21% this quarter, and output may be affected without a deal by year end.
Meta: 10/20, down from our earlier 12. Sales rose 26% to $64.6bn, but this year's capital spending of up to $145bn left free cash flow negative last quarter. A new non-voting share class, mainly for raising money, keeps Mark Zuckerberg firmly in control.
General Motors: 9/20. About 6 times this year's adjusted earnings and big buybacks. But cars are cyclical, and we stripped a $254m one-off gain from the latest quarter. The FT story on hands-off highway driving by 2028 had no numbers.
Verisure: 9/20, a deal situation. CVC is exploring a bid, with no certainty, for the alarm company, which is still below its IPO price a year ago. We would not buy on a rumour.
Netflix: scored 13 yesterday, not rescored. The FT adds job cuts and slower viewing growth.
Mention only: Global stocks fell, Brent rose 3% to $112, and the US 10-year Treasury yield stood at 5.08%. France's 10-year yield gap over Germany is the widest since 2011. Robert Armstrong cites a Brookings estimate that the AI build-out will cost about 3.6% of US GDP a year through 2032, with $466bn of AI debt issued this year. Highland Spring's owners face property defaults (private).
Also on our desk (since Wednesday)
- Lindbergh 12/20 (Wednesday evening X sweep): a founder-run Italian logistics and heating roll-up with good returns, but about 45 times trailing earnings after the shares more than doubled.
- No other new scorecards since yesterday.
Nothing cleared 15 today. With Treasuries yielding over 5%, a business must earn its keep. We are happy to wait.
Research only, not investment advice.
Chronicle