The Calver Chronicle

Published 05:00 GMT+0 · 71 stories

Local
06:40

Dales Green leader says council work goes on after Labour quits alliance, as Lib Dems and Greens lose majority

• The Liberal Democrats and Greens will carry on running Derbyshire Dales District Council without Labour, which has left the council's governing alliance.
• Together with one non-aligned councillor they hold 17 of the 34 seats, which is not a majority.
• Green group leader Cllr Neil Buttle said the council's committee system means he is not sure what difference the split will make.
• Labour's Cllr Simon Ripton is expected to step down as a deputy leader of the council.

Labour has left the alliance that has run Derbyshire Dales since 2023. The party's national executive ended its power-sharing arrangements with the Greens in 11 councils, a move the Chronicle reported yesterday. The district's Labour and Green leaders have now responded. The Local Democracy Reporting Service says the Liberal Democrats, Greens and a non-aligned councillor will continue as a minority administration. Both local leaders pointed to the council's committee system, under which decisions are taken by cross-party committees rather than a cabinet. The Green leader said residents usually raise bins and public toilets on the doorstep.

Photo: Matlock Town Hall, the council's headquarters. Jonathan Thacker / Geograph, CC BY-SA 2.0

Source: Derbyshire Times (Local Democracy Reporting Service); Derbyshire Live. Linked: Derbyshire Times.

The leaders of the Green and Labour groups on Derbyshire Dales District Council have responded after Labour's national executive ordered its councillors to leave the alliance that has run the authority since May 2023. The order followed the Green Party's adoption of a "Zionism is racism" motion at its October conference. The Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS) said the arrangement was a Liberal Democrat-led progressive alliance, not a formal coalition, and that it also included one non-aligned councillor.

According to the LDRS, the Liberal Democrats, the Greens and the non-aligned councillor will continue to run the council as a minority administration. The LDRS gave the council's make-up as 12 Liberal Democrats, nine Conservatives, six Labour, four Greens, two Derbyshire First and one non-aligned councillor. On those figures the remaining partners hold 17 of the 34 seats and the other groups hold 17. The report itself put the administration's total at 15.

so I am not quite sure what difference it will make

Green group leader Cllr Neil Buttle said the council runs a committee system in which every decision has to be ratified by members in a politically proportionate way, "so I am not quite sure what difference it will make". He said the Greens had said none of them would have voted for the motion, but that they would not go against party policy. He also said the issue had never been raised with him while canvassing. "It is normally about bins and public toilets," he said, adding that "the public toilets situation needs tackling".

Earlier in October the Dales Green group had replied to a letter from Labour group leader Cllr Simon Ripton. In that reply the Greens said they rejected the suggestion that the motion, or the Green Party, was antisemitic.

It is normally about bins and public toilets

Cllr Ripton is expected to no longer serve as a deputy leader of the council, according to the LDRS. He said he had not been aware of the national Labour decision before it was announced. "We do have an alliance and not a coalition," he said. He added that because the district has a committee system, work is effectively done on a cross-party basis anyway.

The motion was passed at the Green Party conference by 1,022 votes to 813. Labour has called the policy divisive and antisemitic, and the Green Party says anti-Zionism should not be equated with antisemitism.

We do have an alliance and not a coalition

The council's Governance and Resources Committee meets at Matlock Town Hall at 6pm on Thursday 5 November. Its agenda includes an updated employee probation policy, a communications and marketing strategy, and an external audit progress report.

More from the Morning edition, Wed 4 Nov 2026 →