Labour pulls out of power-sharing with the Greens on Derbyshire Dales council over 'Zionism is racism' policy

• Labour said on Monday it would end power-sharing arrangements with the Green Party on 11 councils, including Derbyshire Dales District Council.
• The move follows a motion passed at the Green Party conference in October declaring that Zionism is racism. Labour had told local Green groups to disown it.
• Derbyshire Dales has been run since 2023 by a Progressive Alliance of Liberal Democrats, Labour and Greens, led by Liberal Democrat Steve Flitter.
• The council's Conservative group welcomed the decision and called on the Liberal Democrats to end their own arrangement with the Greens.
The three-party administration that has run the district council since May 2023 has lost one of its partners. Labour named Derbyshire Dales among 11 authorities where local Green groups had not met its demand to reject the national party's new policy. The council's website lists 12 Liberal Democrat, nine Conservative, six Labour, four Green and two Derbyshire First councillors. The Green Party said it was disappointed. The Chronicle has not seen any statement from the council or its leader on how the district will now be run.
Photo: Matlock Town Hall, the council's headquarters. Jonathan Thacker / Geograph, CC BY-SA 2.0
Source: BBC News; Derbyshire Times; Derbyshire Dales District Council; Derbyshire Dales Conservatives. Linked: BBC News.
The Labour Party announced on Monday 2 November that it would stop sharing power with the Green Party on 11 councils in England, and Derbyshire Dales District Council is one of them. The others named by Labour, according to the BBC, are Arun, Havant, Lewes, Runnymede, Sheffield, Stafford, Warwick, Wealden, West Devon and West Suffolk.
The decision follows a motion titled "Zionism is racism" that was passed by Green Party members at their national conference in October. Labour sent an ultimatum from its head office to councils where it governs with the Greens, telling local Green groups to disown the motion. Labour said it had arrangements with the Greens in 18 authorities and that the conditions had not been met in 11 of them. Labour chair Bridget Phillipson said the policy "crosses a line" and that Labour could not work with any party that supported it, at any level of government.
Derbyshire Dales has been run since May 2023 by what the parties called a Progressive Alliance
The Green Party said it was "hugely disappointed", according to the Derbyshire Times, and said Labour had forced local leaders into jeopardising successful progressive partnerships. The BBC reported that Green Party leader Zack Polanski has called the motion "imperfect" but has defended its central premise.
Derbyshire Dales has been run since May 2023 by what the parties called a Progressive Alliance of the Liberal Democrats, Labour and the Green Party. Conservative control of the council ended at that year's elections. Liberal Democrat Steve Flitter became leader of the council, with the Labour and Green group leaders sharing the role of deputy leader. The council's website currently lists Cllr Flitter as leader and Labour's Simon Ripton and the Green Party's Neil Buttle as deputy leaders.
Together the Liberal Democrats and Greens account for 16 seats
The website lists 33 councillors on the 34-seat council: 12 Liberal Democrats, nine Conservatives, six Labour, four Greens and two from Derbyshire First. Together the Liberal Democrats and Greens account for 16 seats. The BBC said that in the affected areas, Labour and Green councillors would now have to find other partners or try to run their councils as minority administrations.
The council's Conservative group, led by Cllr Stuart Lees, welcomed Labour's decision in a statement on Monday. It noted that the Liberal Democrats' national leadership has left decisions on local partnerships to council groups, and called on the district's Liberal Democrat councillors to end their own power-sharing agreement with the Greens.
Labour and Green councillors would now have to find other partners or try to run their councils as minority administrations
By this morning the Chronicle had not seen any statement from the council, the Liberal Democrat group or the local Labour and Green groups on how the district will be governed from now on. The council's Governance and Resources Committee meets on Thursday 5 November, and the council has said the meeting can be watched online.
Chronicle