Government withdraws plan to abolish Derbyshire Dales council and split the county in two, with a new decision due early next year

• Ministers have withdrawn July's decision to replace Derbyshire's ten councils with two unitary authorities, one for the north and one for the south of the county.
• Under that plan the Derbyshire Dales area, including Calver, Bakewell and Hathersage, would have joined a new northern council.
• The government says reorganisation has not been cancelled, all options remain under consideration and an outcome is due by early next year.
• District council elections go ahead in May 2027 on existing boundaries; new councils are now planned for 2029, with shadow elections in May 2028.
The future shape of local government across the Dales is open again. On Thursday the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government named Derbyshire and Derby among nine areas where earlier decisions on reorganisation have been withdrawn and will be reconsidered. The July plan would have abolished Derbyshire Dales District Council and Derbyshire County Council, placing the district in a northern authority with High Peak, Chesterfield, North East Derbyshire, Bolsover and part of Amber Valley. The county council said it would use the extra time to press its case for a single council covering the whole of Derbyshire. Council services are unaffected for now.
Photo: Matlock Town Hall, headquarters of Derbyshire Dales District Council, in August 2025. Gareth James / Geograph via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0
Source: Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (GOV.UK); Derbyshire County Council; Derbyshire Dales District Council; BBC News; Derbyshire Times. Linked: GOV.UK.
The government has withdrawn its decision to replace Derbyshire's councils with two new unitary authorities, ministers announced on Thursday 29 October. Derbyshire and Derby is one of nine areas where decisions taken in July have been withdrawn and will be reconsidered, the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government said.
In July the government chose a proposal known as option B1, which would have created one council for northern Derbyshire and one for the south. According to Derbyshire Dales District Council, the Dales area would have become part of the northern council together with High Peak, Chesterfield, North East Derbyshire, Bolsover and part of Amber Valley, while Derby, South Derbyshire, Erewash and the rest of Amber Valley would have formed the southern authority. The government paused the plan in September while a review was carried out.
All options and proposals remain under consideration
The ministry said withdrawing the decisions does not mean reorganisation has been cancelled. All options and proposals remain under consideration and every area will have an outcome by early next year. Local elections in the affected areas will go ahead in May 2027 on existing council boundaries, and new councils will be established for 2029, with elections to shadow councils in May 2028.
Areas whose decisions were withdrawn will receive £450,000 for each new unitary authority previously announced, from a £63 million capacity fund, to cover costs already incurred, the ministry added.
Every area will have an outcome by early next year
Derbyshire County Council said it welcomed the additional time to engage with the government on its preferred option of a single authority serving the whole county. Its leader, Councillor Alan Graves, said any transition must be managed carefully while services continue to be delivered safely.
Derbyshire Dales District Council did not submit its own proposal for reorganisation. Its website says councillors were unable to endorse the case for change.
New councils will be established for 2029, with elections to shadow councils in May 2028
The July plan would have split Amber Valley between the two new councils, and the BBC and Derbyshire Times reported that Amber Valley Borough Council had begun a process that could lead to a legal challenge. The Local Government Association said councils affected needed urgent clarity on next steps and on how costs already incurred would be met.
There are no immediate changes to council services, and residents should continue to contact the district and county councils in the usual way.
Chronicle